Page History

Avoid the use of in-band error indicators. These are much less common in Java than in some other programming languages, but they are used in the read(byte[] b, int off, int len) and read(char[] cbuf, int off, int len) family of methods in java.io.

In Java, the best way to indicate an exceptional situation is by throwing an exception, rather than by returning an error code. Exceptions cannot be ignored in the same way that error codes can, and exceptions are propagated across scopes. When using exceptions, the error detection and error handling code is kept separate from the main flow of control. Also, exceptions can be used in situations where error codes cannot be returned (in constructors, for example).

Noncompliant Code Example

...

However, if the input buffer is initially at end-of-file then the read method will return -1 and the attempt to place the termintor character will throw an ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException.

Compliant Solution (Extending)

This compliant solution defines a SafeBufferedReader class and introduces a readSafe method that throws an exception if end-of-file is detected.

class SafeBufferedReader extends BufferedReader {
   SafeBufferedReader(Reader in) {
      super(in);
   }

   public int readSafe(char[] cbuf, int off, int len) throws EOFException {
      int read = read(cbuf, off, len);
      if (read == -1) {
         throw new EOFException();
      } else {
         return read;
      }
   }
}

// ...

SafeBufferedReader safeBuffRdr;

try {
   read = safeBuffRdr.readSafe(chBuff, 0, MAX_READ);
   chBuff[read] = TERMINATOR;
} catch (EOFException eof) {
   chBuff[0] = TERMINATOR;
}

Compliant Solution (Wrapping)

This compliant solution defines a readSafe method that wraps the original read method and throws an exception if end-of-file is detected.

public static int readSafe(BufferedReader buffer, char[] cbuf, int off, int len) throws EOFException {
  int read = buffer.read(cbuf, off, len);
  if (read == -1) {
     throw new EOFException();
  } else {
     return read;
  }
}

// ...

BufferedReader buffRdr;

// set up buffRdr

try {
   read = readSafe(buffRdr, chBuff, 0, MAX_READ);
   chBuff[read] = TERMINATOR;
} catch (EOFException eof) {
   chBuff[0] = TERMINATOR;
}

Risk Assessment

Using in-band error indicators may result in programmers failing to check status codes or using incorrect return values, resulting in undefined behavior.

Automated Detection

Given the comparatively rare occurrence of in-band error indicators in Java, it may be possible to compile a list of all methods that use them and automatically detect their use. However, detecting the safe use of in-band error indicators is not feasible.

...