IDS30-PL. Exclude user input from format strings

Never call any formatted I/O function with a format string containing user input.

An attacker who can fully or partially control the contents of a format string can crash the Perl interpreter, or cause a denial of service. She can also modify values, perhaps by using the %n|| conversion specifier, and use these values to divert control flow. Their capabilities are not as strong as in C [Seacord 2005], nonetheless the danger is sufficiently great that the formatted output functions {{sprintf() and printf() should never be passed unsanitized format strings.

Noncompliant Code Example

This noncompliant code example tries to authenticate a user by having them supply a password, and only granting them access if the password is correct.

sub validate_password {
  my ($prompt, $password) = @_;
  my $is_ok = ($password eq "goodpass");
  printf "$prompt: Password ok? %d\n", $is_ok;
  return $is_ok;
};

my $host = `hostname`;
chop($host);
my $prompt = "$ENV{USER}\@$host";
if (validate_password( $prompt, $ARGV[0])) {
  print "$prompt: access granted\n";
} else {
  print "$prompt: access denied\n";
};

The program works as expected as long as the username and hostname are benign:

user@host:~$ ./authenticate.pl goodpass
user@host: Password ok? 1
user@host: access granted
user@host:~$ ./authenticate.pl badpass
user@host: Password ok? 0
user@host: access denied
user@host:~$

However, the program can be foiled by a malicious username:

user@host:~$ env USER=user%n ./authenticate.pl badpass
user%n@host: Password ok? 0
user%n@host: access granted
user@host:~$

In this invocation, the malicious username user%n was incomprorated into the $prompt string. When fed to the printf() call inside validate_password(), the %n instructed Perl to fill the first format string argument with the number of characters printed. This caused Perl to set the $is_ok variable to 4. Since it is now nonzero, the program incorrectly grants access to the user.

Compliant Solution (`print()`)

This compliant solution avoids the use of printf() since print() provides sufficient functionality.

sub validate_password {
  my ($prompt, $password) = @_;
  my $is_ok = ($password eq "goodpass");
  print "$prompt: Password ok? $is_ok\n";
  return $is_ok;
};

# ...