FIO13-J. Do not log sensitive information outside a trust boundary

Logging is essential for debugging, incident response, and collecting forensic evidence. Nevertheless, logging sensitive data raises many concerns, including the privacy of the stakeholders, limitations imposed by the law on the collection of personal information, and the potential for data exposure by insiders. Sensitive information includes, but is not limited to, IP addresses, user names and passwords, email addresses, credit card numbers and any personally identifiable information such as social security numbers. Many countries prohibit or restrict collection of personal data; others permit retention of personal data only when held in an anonymized form. Consequently, logs must not contain sensitive data, particularly when prohibited by law.

Unfortunately, violations of this rule are common. For example, prior to version 0.8.1, the LineControl Java client logged sensitive information, including the local user's password, as documented by CVE-2005-2990.

The java.util.logging class provides a basic logging framework for JDK versions 1.4 and higher. Other logging frameworks exist, but the basic principles apply regardless of the particular logging framework chosen.

Programs must typically support varying levels of protection. Some information, such as access times, can be safely logged. Some information can be logged, but the log file must be restricted from everyone but particular administrators. Other information, such as credit card numbers, can only be logged in encrypted form. Other information, such as passwords, should not be logged at all.

For these code samples, we will assume that the log in question lies outside the trust boundary of the information being sent to it. Also, normal log messages should include additional parameters such as date, time, source event, and so forth. This information has been omitted from our examples for brevity.

Noncompliant Code Example

In this noncompliant code example, a server logs the IP address of the remote client in the event of a security exception. This data can be misused, for example, to build a profile of a user's browsing habits. Such logging may violate legal restrictions in many countries.

If the log cannot contain IP addresses, it should not contain any information about a SecurityException. When an exception contains sensitive information, the custom MyExceptionReporter class should extract or cleanse it, before returning control to the next statement in the catch block (see ERR00-J. Do not suppress or ignore checked exceptions).

The MyExceptionReporter.handle() method may also do its own logging, after filtering out sensitive information.

public void logRemoteIPAddress(String name) {
  Logger logger = Logger.getLogger("com.organization.Log");
  InetAddress machine = null;
  try {
    machine = InetAddress.getByName(name);
  } catch (UnknownHostException e) {
    Exception e = MyExceptionReporter.handle(e);
  } catch (SecurityException e) {
    Exception e = MyExceptionReporter.handle(e);
    logger.severe(name + "," + machine.getHostAddress() + "," + e.toString());
  }
}

Compliant Solution

This compliant solution does not log security exceptions, except for the logging implicitly performed by MyExceptionReporter.

   // ...
  catch (SecurityException e) {
    Exception e = MyExceptionReporter.handle(e);
  }

Noncompliant Code Example

Log messages with sensitive information should not be printed to the console display for security reasons (a possible example might be passenger age). The java.util.logging.Logger class supports different logging levels that can be used for classifying such information. These are FINEST, FINER, FINE, CONFIG, INFO, WARNING, and SEVERE. By default, the INFO, WARNING, and SEVERE levels print the message to the console, which is accessible by end users and system administrators.

If we assume that the passenger age can appear in log files on the current system but not on the console display, this code example is noncompliant.

logger.info("Age: " + passengerAge);

Compliant Solution

This compliant solution logs the passenger age at the FINEST level to prevent this information from displaying on the console. As noted above, we are assuming the age may appear in system log files, but not on the console.

// make sure that all handlers only print log messages rated INFO or higher
Handler handlers[] = logger.getHandlers();
for (int i = 0; i < handlers.length; i++) {
  handlers[i].setLevel(Level.INFO);
}
// ...
logger.finest("Age: " + passengerAge);

Risk Assessment

Logging sensitive information can violate system security policies and can violate user privacy when the logging level is incorrect or when the log files are insecure.

Related Vulnerabilities

Search for vulnerabilities resulting from the violation of this rule on the CERT website.

Related Guidelines

Bibliography

      12. Input Output (FIO)