MET00-J. Understand the difference between overriding and hiding

An instance method defined in a subclass can override another instance method in the superclass when:

• Both have the same name
• Number and type of parameters is same
• Return type is same

The Hiding term is used in context of a class method (or field) that has the same signature as the corresponding class method (or field) in the superclass or superinterface.

The difference between these two is that the overridden method gets invoked from the subclass while the hidden method may get invoked from either the superclass or the subclass, depending on how it is invoked (name qualification).

Noncompliant Code Example

To differentiate between overriding and hiding, a common nomenclature is used. The method to be invoked is decided at either compile time (if the base method is static, as in this noncompliant example) according to the type of the qualifier or at run time otherwise (for non-static methods). A qualifier is a part of the invocation expression before the dot (for example, admin and user here).

This noncompliant example attempts to override a static method but fails to consider it as a hiding case. As a result the displayAccountStatus method of the superclass gets invoked on both the calls. Moreover, expressions that are normally used for dynamic dispatch while overriding have been used even though achieving this is impossible with static methods.

class GrantAccess {
  public static void displayAccountStatus() {
    System.out.print("Account details for admin: XX");
  }
}

class GrantUserAccess extends GrantAccess {
  public static void displayAccountStatus() {
    System.out.print("Account details for user: XX");
  }
}

public class StatMethod {
  public static void choose(String username) {
    GrantAccess admin = new GrantAccess();
    GrantAccess user = new GrantUserAccess();
    if(username.equals("admin"))
      admin.displayAccountStatus();
    else
      user.displayAccountStatus();
  }

  public static void main(String[] args) {
    choose("user");	
  }
}

Compliant Solution

This compliant solution correctly classifies this case as hiding and uses absolute class names GrantAccess and GrantUserAccess to clearly state the intent. Refrain from qualifying a static method invocation with an expression meant for dynamic dispatch.

class GrantAccess {
  public static void displayAccountStatus() {
    System.out.print("Account details for admin: XX");
  }
}

class GrantUserAccess extends GrantAccess {
  public static void displayAccountStatus() {
    System.out.print("Account details for user: XX");
  }
}

public class StatMethod {
  public static void choose(String username) {
  if(username.equals("admin"))
    GrantAccess.displayAccountStatus();
  else
    GrantUserAccess.displayAccountStatus();
  }
  
  public static void main(String[] args) {
    choose("user");	
  }
}

Note that "In a subclass, you can overload the methods inherited from the superclass. Such overloaded methods neither hide nor override the superclass methods—they are new methods, unique to the subclass." [[Tutorials 08]]

Technically, a private method cannot be hidden or overridden. There is no requirement that private methods with the same signature in the subclass and the superclass bear any relationship in terms of having the same return type or throws clause, the necessary conditions for hiding. [[JLS 05]]. Consequently, there may be no hiding when the methods have different return types or throws clauses.

It is recommended that the @Override annotation be used to clearly specify that a method is the overridden version and not the hidden one.

Risk Assessment

Confusing overriding and hiding can produce unexpected results.

Automated Detection

TODO

Related Vulnerabilities

Search for vulnerabilities resulting from the violation of this rule on the CERT website.

References

[[Tutorials 08]] Overriding and Hiding Methods
[[Bloch 05]] Puzzle 48: All I Get Is Static
[[JLS 05]] 8.4.6.3 Requirements in Overriding and Hiding

10. Methods (MET)      10. Methods (MET)      MET01-J. Follow good design principles while defining methods